Winnipesaukee Muskrats (New England Collegiate Baseball League) @ Robbie Mills Field (Laconia, NH)

This is the story of one of my old baseball trips. The trip occurred BEFORE I started truly writing stuff about stadiums in earnest, and I don’t remember every single detail about it, but a few stand out to me for reasons you’ll see soon enough.

July 30, 2022.

As July turns into August, summer collegiate baseball begins to wind down. Many of the players have colleges to get back to, but there are still playoffs to be played and champions to be determined (which, unfortunately, has contributed to a decline in summer league participation; more on that later). Finding myself with nothing to do, and wanting to find SOMETHING, I look around at the schedule of the New England Collegiate Baseball League and find one game that piques my interest:

"Keene Swamp Bats vs. Winnipesaukee Muskrats"

After a quick Google Maps search to see just how far they are, I decided to make the trip up to Laconia, NH to watch this game - a drive of about two hours.

Laconia is part of the Lakes Region of New Hampshire which, like many places in Northern New England, is somewhat reliant on tourism as its main money maker - after all, one of its big attractions is its local arcade believed to be the biggest in the world.

The Muskrats themselves were founded in 1999 in Manchester, CT (just east of Hartford). They spent a little over a decade there, and in 2010, the team was "sold" and moved to the Lakes Region. Originally, they used Laconia as their geographic identifier, but changed it to Winnipesaukee in 2015 to better connect to the region as a whole (as Lake Winnipesaukee is the largest of the lakes). While it is fairly difficult to gauge the success of summer collegiate teams by regular season/postseason records for MANY reasons, the Muskrats...weren’t exactly major players in that department. They made the playoffs a total of ten times between their stints in Manchester and the Lakes region, but only won two playoff rounds - both in 2011, where they lost the finals to their in-state rivals in Keene (i.e. the aforementioned Swamp Bats).

Their home base was Robbie Mills Field: a small community field in a rather sprawling part of Laconia. Named after a young child who was tragically killed in an apparent bikejacking, it features "dugouts" which are, in essence, small sheds next to the infield plus a high wall in left field. This wall was "under construction" at the time; I forget what the plan was, but I believe it involved putting seats on top of it (a la the Green Monster at Fenway Park). There’s also a small parking lot on the first base side, but the team did NOT recommend parking there due to the possibility of foul balls damaging cars (something that ALMOST happened to me on Cape Cod once); instead, the team directed fans to park across the street in a large field.

Probably the most important part of the field is the building behind home plate. Like a lot of these smaller summer league fields around New England (for example: most of the Cape Cod Baseball League), it serves as the "everything building". On the upper level is the press box; if you walked near it during the game, you could hear broadcasters for both teams call the action. On the lower level, the building houses the concession stand and team store, but in a somewhat unique way: concessions are sold on the "back" side of the building (i.e. away from the field), and merchandise can be purchased on the other side of the building facing the field.

Most summer collegiate teams in New England don’t sell merchandise online due to how small their operations are, so games are often the only way to get items from these teams. However, due to various difficulties involving costs and shipping, some teams don’t order that much merchandise for fans, and thus selections are still limited at games - especially as the season wears on. Thankfully, despite it being the last home date of the season, the Muskrats still had a decent number of merchandise items available. I end up buying their standard home hat (though, to be honest, it’s not exactly "fashionable" as it features the team’s FULL NAME on the front), a "fashion hat" featuring the team’s muskrat logo, and a game used jersey featuring a "LACONIA" wordmark (reflecting how they were once the "Laconia Muskrats"). In addition, they allowed me to take a lanyard for free.

I don’t remember too much about the game (outside of giving a foul ball to a young child), but as I was about to head out for the day (partially because I decided to check out another game closer to Boston), I ended up running into a British man. We had a fifteen minute conversation about life in Laconia and the NECBL, and it was very clear that he was heavily involved with the team, as he discussed stories about things such as the awkward logistics for the team’s lone representative at the league’s All Star Game that year (which was held on Martha's Vineyard - a HIKE from just about everywhere).

However, the story doesn’t QUITE end here. Despite the Swamp Bats and Muskrats splitting a double header, there’s still a little bit of an unsettled business; I have forgotten the EXACT details of it, but there was a chance for either the Muskrats or some other team to make the NECBL postseason - potentially requiring a "makeup" game to be played. I went to Sanford, ME the next day to see the end of a game between the Swamp Bats and the Sanford Mainers, and since the Mainers won that game, they clinched the playoff berth - thus rendering the makeup game between Winnipesaukee and the Upper Valley Nighthawks (from White River Junction, VT) irrelevant¹.

Months later, when the NECBL releases its 2023 schedule, I look at it since I was planning to visit all 14 of its teams that summer (protip: don't - some of these teams are HIKES). However, when I count up the teams, I realize that one is missing. I go through the list of names, and I find that the Winnipesaukee Muskrats are no longer listed on the NECBL’s website.

The man I spent a good fifteen minutes talking to on that summer day was the husband of the team’s GM. After the 2022 season, she decided to step down from the role, and the team/league began the process of replacing her. However, in doing so, the league decided to conduct a review of the Muskrats organization (I believe this is standard protocol when a change like this happens); unfortunately, this review turned up something the league did not agree with: housing plans.

Most collegiate summer leagues require that the players live with families local to the team for the summer (the Cape Cod Baseball League and NECBL included). However, with the Lakes region being a popular tourist destination, many homeowners in the area seemingly prefer to use their space as vacation rentals (my guess is that the stipends provided by the NECBL don’t compare to what tourists are willing to pay). Thus, the Muskrats were forced to get creative with housing players - attempting a plan which I don’t remember the full details of. The plan was rejected by the NECBL, and without being able to come to any agreements...the Winnipesaukee Muskrats were no more.

As for a potential return of summer baseball to the Lakes...

There’s a report out that fewer players are joining these summer leagues as their college coaches don’t like sending them to the "uncontrolled environment" that is summer ball (read: more injury and/or transfer potential), so I do ponder what future these leagues have. In addition, most NECBL and Cape League teams are meant to be community assets, so their facilities are, for lack of a better term, not what most college players are used to (most especially the ones from high-end programs). The Cape League - which has long been touted as the best of the summer leagues - is struggling to deal with these issues; for example, it reduced its schedule to 40 games a few years ago, and seemingly has constant need for new host families (as teams put out calls for them EVERY year²).

While the NECBL hasn’t gained or lost any teams since then, the Futures League has seen the Brockton Rox "leave" and the Pittsfield Suns "go inactive" for SEVERAL years (due to their stadium needing wholescale redevelopment), but is also adding Lowell to its ranks. I doubt it’s likely, but if things continue to go south for summer ball, I can see a future where the NECBL and Futures League are forced to merge due to resources becoming incredibly sparse - likely costing several towns their teams.

As it turns out, my spontaneous decision was a "good" one: I was at the (second to) last Winnipesaukee Muskrats game ever. No one could have imagined that July 30, 2022 would be the last day of baseball in the Lakes region, but it was, and I fear that as the college baseball landscape shifts towards having players "stay safe" in the summer, more and more summer baseball teams will find survival incredibly challenging.

I hope that you enjoyed this piece. It's quite different from most of what I post here, but I felt it was good for me to try and branch out to other forms of writing/content.

I've had this post ready to go for a while, but my original intention was to post this in July to match the date this game took place. However, if you couldn't tell...I moved it up QUITE A BIT. You'll see why tomorrow.